Does No State Income Tax Make a Place Cheaper? Not Really.
Places in states without a wage income tax have about the same home values and regional prices as everywhere else, and against their own neighbors the no-tax states split evenly: four with higher home values, four with lower.
Published November 9, 2026 · 5 min read · Let's Live There editorial · Updated November 9, 2026
We checked 4,395 places across the United States, and on the big question the answer is close to a wash. In the nine states that skip a wage income tax, the middle place has a typical home value of $349,100; across the remaining states and DC it is $343,000, a gap of 1.78%. Regional prices barely differ either, with an index median of 100.3 for the no-tax states against 100.1 for the rest. If you were hoping that a missing income tax line on your pay stub came bundled with cheaper houses or lower everyday prices, the national numbers don't show it.
The sharper test is next door, and there the result is an exact split. Four of the no-tax states have higher home values than the places just across their borders, and four have lower ones. Alaska, with no neighboring state, sits this one out. A state without an income tax turns up on the lower-home-value side of its border exactly as often as on the higher side.
A state without an income tax turns up on the lower-home-value side of its border exactly as often as on the higher side.
Scroll sideways for more columns
| State | State home value / regional prices | Neighbors home value / regional prices | All other home value / regional prices |
|---|---|---|---|
| Alaska | $325,400 / 103.2 | Unavailable | $345,550 / 100.1 |
| Florida | $366,000 / 100.9 | $265,100 / 91.9 | $341,300 / 99.8 |
| Nevada | $433,200 / 100.2 | $586,900 / 106.4 | $344,000 / 100.1 |
| New Hampshire | $391,200 / 105.7 | $495,350 / 102.5 | $344,500 / 100.1 |
| South Dakota | $230,700 / 86.7 | $294,500 / 91.6 | $346,800 / 100.1 |
| Tennessee | $286,400 / 92.2 | $261,800 / 92.9 | $347,150 / 100.2 |
| Texas | $266,850 / 98.1 | $200,050 / 87.45 | $352,100 / 100.2 |
| Washington | $557,000 / 111.1 | $433,450 / 101.5 | $337,600 / 100.0 |
| Wyoming | $280,900 / 91.6 | $467,200 / 98.2 | $346,500 / 100.1 |
Opens that place's page. It may not be in this comparison; the method note says who was left out.
Washington, Florida, Texas and Tennessee are the four with higher home values than their neighbors. Washington's middle place is valued at $557,000, against $433,450 across the line in Oregon and Idaho, and its regional price index of 111.1 tops theirs at 101.5. Florida, at $366,000, sits well above the $265,100 in neighboring Alabama and Georgia. Texas comes in at $266,850 against $200,050 in Arkansas, Louisiana, New Mexico and Oklahoma, with a price index of 98.1 to their 87.45. Tennessee is the narrow case: its $286,400 beats the $261,800 in the states around it, yet its regional prices, at 92.2, are a hair under theirs at 92.9. In all four, the tax-free side of the border is the more expensive side for housing.
South Dakota and Wyoming are where the cheap-and-tax-free picture holds. South Dakota's middle place is valued at $230,700, against $294,500 across its neighbors, with a regional price index of 86.7 to their 91.6. Wyoming comes in at $280,900 next to $467,200 for a neighbor pool that takes in Colorado and Utah, and its price index of 91.6 sits under their 98.2. Here, housing and everyday prices both run lower than in the surrounding states.
Nevada and New Hampshire have lower home values than their neighbors too, with one caveat. Most of the places around Nevada are in California, and most of those around New Hampshire are in Massachusetts, so their pooled neighbor medians lean toward those big neighbors. Nevada's middle place is valued at $433,200, well under $586,900 next door, and its price index of 100.2 trails their 106.4. New Hampshire comes in at $391,200 against $495,350, though its regional prices, at 105.7, actually run above the neighbors' 102.5. Set against all other places nationwide, where the comparable medians are $344,000 and $344,500, both states' home values sit on the high side. Coming in under a neighborhood shaped by California and Massachusetts is a real result, but a low bar.
Alaska has no neighboring state, so its only yardstick is the rest of the country. Its middle place is valued at $325,400 against $345,550 elsewhere, but its regional price index runs higher, 103.2 to 100.1: the homes cost less, while local prices overall cost more.
So a missing state income tax is a poor shorthand for cheap. Among the nine, South Dakota and Wyoming come in lower than their neighbors on both home values and everyday prices, while Washington, Florida and Texas run higher on both. If you are weighing a move across a particular border, compare that pair of states directly rather than assuming the tax-free side is the bargain.
If low taxes and affordable housing both matter to you, take our survey and see which places come up.
Method and sources
Method. 4,395 places checked; 4,388 eligible and 7 excluded under the pinned measured-tax, positive-home-value and regional-price rules. ACS 2020–2024 owner-reported home values are not listings; regional prices are BEA 2024 metro/nonmetro indexes, US = 100. Tax classification uses the pinned Tax Foundation 2025 wage-income-tax schedule. The nine states are AK, FL, NV, NH, SD, TN, TX, WA and WY. Medians pool eligible places, without population weighting. Neighbors share a US-state boundary, excluding point-only and maritime-only contact; all other places means outside the focal state, including DC. Alaska has no US-state neighbor: unavailable, never zero. The overall benchmark compares the nine states with the remaining states and DC. Descriptive, not causal. Dataset commit 96216201cfdc59d2afe0b2b79d3ae6cc3be2eef4.
Places in this story
Show 1 source
Write to the editor
Spotted an error? Tell us privately. A person reads every note; nothing is published.